Question: Why Does Elie Some Years Later Ask A Lady Not To Throw Money To The Poor?

Why does the doctor lie to Elie?

When Elie is in the work camp, his foot swells from the cold, and a Jewish doctor tells him that he will operate on his foot.

The doctor says that if Elie waits, he risks having an amputation.

Later, after Buchenwald is liberated, Elie becomes ill from a kind of poison and also spends some time in a hospital..

What is ironic about Elie’s decision to leave the hospital?

What is the ironic statement, “I’ve got more faith in Hitler than in anyone else. … What is ironic about the choice Elie and his father make concerning staying in the hospital or evacuating with the others in his unit? Elie later found out that the people that were left behind that day were liberated.

What sickness does Elie’s father come down with?

Confined to his bed, Eliezer’s father continues to approach death. He is afflicted with dysentery, which makes him terribly thirsty, but it is extremely dangerous to give water to a man with dysentery. Eliezer tries to find medical help for his father, to no avail.

What choice does each man have at Auschwitz?

What choice does each man have at Auschwitz? They have the option to work or go to the crematorium. What advice does the Polish prisoner in charge of their barracks give before that are allowed to lie down in a bunk?

What stops Elie from giving up and dying?

The Blockaltest (head of the block) suggests that Elie stops giving his dying father his portions of food. He says that it’s “every man for himself” here and Elie cannot help his father anymore.

What stares back at Elie at the end of the novel?

What stares back at Elie at the end of the novel? Elie’s reflection on a mirror stares back at him, he describes the image as a living corpse.

Who does Elie say stronger than God?

Elie wrote that man was stronger than God.

Why does Elie regard the weak starving prisoners?

Why does Elie regard the weak, starving prisoners as stronger than God? He feels they are stronger than god because they are living even with being starved and weak. How does Elie show his rebellion against God? What advice is given to the prisoners before a selection?

What happens when a worker throws a piece of bread into the wagon?

When the workman throws bread into the wagon, everyone turns to animals. They start clawing and biting each other just to get a crumb of bread. Elie sees a son kill his father for the piece of bread he had and then two men killed the son to get the piece of bread. … Wiesel’s life was dull.

What does Elie dream about at his weakest point?

He imagined a world with no bells. What happened to the patients who stayed in the hospital instead of being evacuated? They were liberated by the Russians two days after the others left.

What is the most important goal for Elie?

What is the most important goal for Elie as he enters the camp? His main goal is to stay with his father.

Why does Elie say there was no more reason to live no more reason to struggle when he wakes up to snow covered open cattle car?

Why does Elie say, “there was no more reason to live, no more reason to struggle” when he wakes up to a snow covered, open cattle car? He thought his father was dead, and he then believed that there was no reason for him to continue fighting, because if his father wasn’t there then he didn’t want to be.

What happens to Elie’s father when he continues to ask for water?

Elie tries to get his father to a doctor and give him food. What happens to Elie’s father when he continues to ask for water? The other inmates get mad because of his groaning and his dysentery just gets worse due to the water. … they didn’t feed them because they were going to die soon and it would be a waste of food.

What does Elie’s father want to tell him before he dies?

Terms in this set (25) When they got into the camp what did Elie’s father do? He wanted to lay down in the snow and die.

How old is Elie at the end of Chapter 7?

fifteen yearsEliezer resolves not to fight for the food and notices one man who kills his own father for a piece of bread. Then, the son is killed for the same bread, and both father and son lie dead side by side. Eliezer notes at this point in the narrative that he is fifteen years old.

How does Elie’s father die?

Mr Wiesel’s mother and one sister were killed in Nazi death chambers. His father died of starvation and dysentery in the Buchenwald camp.

Why can’t Elie weep at his father’s death?

For Wiesel and his father, they stuck together until the bitter end. … Why can’t Eliezer weep at his father’s death? He had no more tears but at the same time, his father was no longer a burden to him so he essentially was free. When he is finally free, Elie looks at himself in a mirror.

Why didn’t he see his father died?

He does not see his father die because he was sleeping and he does not cry because he was all out of tears. … Wiesel is sent to a hospital after his liberation because he had some type of poisoning that left him between life and death.

What were Shlomo’s last words?

This was all the ration of soup they got in one day. The head of block said that Elie should be taking his father’s ration. Elie sits with his father for the rest of the night in his bunk. Shlomo says his final word that night and it was, “Eliezer”.

Why do you suppose Elie then tells the story about the woman throwing coins to the natives?

More people threw in bread and watched prisoners fight for food. Why does Elie then tell the story about the women throwing coins to the natives? He is making it clear that the actions of the workman were not acts of charity. … A son beat his father to death over bread.

What was Elie’s father’s last words?

He assumes that his father has been taken to the crematory and recalls that his father’s final word was “Eliezer.” Too weary for tears, Elie realizes that death has liberated him from a doomed, irretrievable burden.